Thoughts,
Questions, and Reflections on Eating Disorders and Body Image
Have you known someone with an eating disorder? What do you think this is all about? Is there a role for us as pharmacists or women? It is a complex area and requires a lot of understanding. Long term complications can be alterations of the GI tract/ esophagus and of course - associated osteoporosis. What would you say to someone who asked about weight-loss products in the pharmacy? What if they looked already under healthy weight?
You don’t have to address all of these – they are
simply to get you thinking. Did you find
"Dying to be Thin" interesting or did you feel like you already knew much of it?? Have you known someone with an eating disorder? What do you think this is all about? Is there a role for us as pharmacists or women? It is a complex area and requires a lot of understanding. Long term complications can be alterations of the GI tract/ esophagus and of course - associated osteoporosis. What would you say to someone who asked about weight-loss products in the pharmacy? What if they looked already under healthy weight?
Several other associated eating conditions exist in our society from anorexia and bulimia to binge eating and obesity. Sometimes young women decide to control all food in a desire to modify how they look – sometimes they harshly judge their own body. Sometimes it is a reaction to family member such as their Mother. Sometimes it is just a desire to have control over some aspect of their life. Following class and the readings - think about your contact with this patient population.
How you encountered individuals in your high school or college days that made you wonder about eating disorders? How did you react or act? How does an eating disorder present in young men? What factors are present in men? What is the role of a pharmacist? How will you use this information? What is the role of drug therapy? At this time, we have not a lot of ways to help with drug therapy other than to buy time while the patient has psychotherapy. In a few years (5-10) we may have a lot more control over leptin and it might revolutionize therapy.
What thoughts do you have?
Here are 3 YouTube videos on Eating Disorders - from Dr. Phil
The documentary we watched in class this past week was very eye-opening. I definitely took a lot out of the experience that I didn't know before.
ReplyDeleteFor one, I did not realize that treatment for diseases such as bulimia and anorexia was not covered by insurance. Not only are these disorders topics people don't like to discuss, they are deadly diseases that oftentimes go untreated. I did not realize how intensive the therapy for such disorders is and how largely unavailable it is to the average citizen. I feel this is counter-productive and can only lead to harm.
Another thing I have taken away from the past two weeks is how widely promoted unhealthy eating disorders are in certain professions such as modeling and dancing. Though I understand it is the way of the world and everyone can't be a model or professional dancer, I don't believe these practices are right.
In general, I feel like the biggest problem surrounding body image and eating disorders in America is the refusal to address the issue. These are things easier to sweep under the rug instead of facing head on. As long as these problems are kept in the shadows, they will never change. The first step to solving a problem is admitting that there is one.
I agree with Ryan in that the biggest problem regarding eating disorders is that we do not address them. I understand this is a touchy subject, but I fell like we would be able to help more patients if we started to ask more questions.
ReplyDeleteI can recall one instance that happened to me where I became offended. I was at my yearly check-up at the doctors office. My appointment was in the morning and I hadn't eaten breakfast yet. The scale said I weighed about 5 pounds less than the previous year, but I had been working out and eating much healthier since my cholesterol was running high. When the doctor came in and saw that my weight had dropped she remarked, "Are you eating food?" I was shocked because of course I was eating food! I thought to myself, "What? I do not even look anorexic and I am at a healthy weight for my height." I was very offended and put off, I ended up switching doctors over time. I cannot imagine how offended others can be when they actually have a body image issue and an eating disorder. When others address eating disorders like it is a joke or a minuscule problem, it can really be offensive.
I have known a couple friends where they take pride in not eating all day and say, "oh, this is my first meal today". We all want to lose weight and be healthier, but starving ourselves is going to do more harm than a couple pounds of weight loss. I think pharmacists can play a big part in healthy eating habits and nutrition. We can also hopefully be of even more help in the future when more drugs are developed to increase appetite or control weight loss.
I will also agree that one of the major problems is that eating disorders are not addressed very well. One of the reasons I was interested in this course in the first place is because my older sister is bulimic. She is currently getting outpatient treatment, but I only found out recently and this is something she has been battling for 10 years! But it was very rarely talked about in my family even though looking back it was very clear she was too skinny for her health; I just assumed it was due to the stress of her job or something. I regret not trying to talk to her about it earlier.
ReplyDeleteDiscovering her eating disorder, it has been frustrating for me because it is difficult to help someone with an eating disorder. I felt very helpless not understanding what exactly she was going through or how to help her. Even with a pharmacy background, options are limited.
As of now, I feel like a pharmacist’s role is just to encourage healthy eating and exercise habits as well as therapy if a patient needs it. There may be medications one day, but I think it will take a while before there is an efficacious drug therapy option.
until we watched that documentary last week, it didnt hit me just how prevalent and how dangerous anorexic eating disorders can be. i feel that our responsibility when we are all medical professionals one day is to guide others away from lifestyles that can negatively impact one's health. part of the biggest challenge is going to be making someone see that the the short term effects of being thin will greatly impact their health down the road.
ReplyDeleteThe women in the video using the walker to cross the street is a prime example of these consequences that follow extreme dieting. Even though she invested all her effort to becoming a successful ballet dancer, i cant imagine the regret that women carries with her on a daily basis.
I agree with Sarah that it is difficult to help someone with an eating disorder. I had a roommate with an eating disorder, and I actually had no idea she had the eating disorder until she told me. After she told me, looking back I could see some signs that made it very clear. I found myself often battling whether or not to say anything to her. When I did mention something little, such as asking her how much she had eaten that day, she would get very defensive. I knew she didn't like to talk about it, and I felt like there wasn't really a lot I could do, so I found myself ignoring the problem. I really wish I would have tried to help her more. Especially after seeing how detrimental it really can be to your health. The woman in the video with the walker was pretty shocking to me. I guess I didn't really expect the health issues to be that severe.
ReplyDeleteAnother thing I thought was interesting was when you told us about how some people with eating disorders will go through the grocery store and fill their whole cart and then leave it in the aisle. They get to experience food without actually eating it. I can't imagine being able to do that. Most people get hungrier and can't resist eating or buying food when they are surrounded by it or smelling it. I would have thought that those that restricted food would just try to stay very far away from it so they wouldn't be tempted, so that was really interesting to me.
I am always squeamish when I see a picture of a person who is severely anorexic or way too skinny. It scares me how much someone will starve themselves to the point they are killing themselves. I found the lecture and movie very eye opening. We talked about signs that someone has an eating disorder such as being obsessed with food, weight and calories or having an obsession with perfection. I thought these were just normal traits of most girls. Many of my friends exhibit traits such as this and I have never really thought anything of it. I figured if they were not super skinny, then nothing was wrong. I think what I took away most from the movie is that you don’t have to be thin to have an eating disorder. It can be an unhealthy perception of yourself or acting in ways that are harming your body even though you don’t realize it.
ReplyDeleteIn my town, there was a girl whose family we are close with who had an eating disorder. All through middle school and high school she struggled with food and her weight. Her parents sent her to multiple facilities and therapists trying to get her the help she needed. Girls from our school were cruel and she struggled with this problem into college. She dropped out of college and soon had kidney failure and went blind. She was in and out of the hospital and had to be resuscitated many times during surgery. She eventually died this past year at the age of 27 and it was heartbreaking. She was a beautiful woman who was nowhere near fat. She had a terrible self-image of herself and low self-esteem that she never could change. She had loving parents who did their best to get her help but it was not enough. I think with everything we have talked about in the past few weeks with how the media portrays women and how women perceive themselves, it is important to remember that beauty is not just what you see in a magazine or on a billboard. It is not worth your life to achieve this appearance so many strive to have.
I really feel that this is a very sensitive and difficult topic. Many people who suffer do not want to talk about it or get offended when someone tries. As healthcare professionals, I think this area will be really difficult for us to offer help in. If we do try to offer our help or assistance patients may think we are overstepping our boundaries.
ReplyDeleteI was also really surprised at the many long term effects. I knew that there would be immediate medical concerns but did not realize the potential for osteoporosis and other medical conditions. I think if we do try to make this a priority of care for our future than this is where our aim should be. We should teach girls about the long term effects.
I was also really surprised that eating disorders were accepted for dancers, models, and gymnast. This is very sad to me. I wonder how young girls can possible be healthy and not give in to pressures when they feel that they have no other choice but to stop eating.
This comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteIt was such a relief to hear her new dance teacher say that it was something she needed to address and a healthy lifestyle was important!
DeleteWatching dying to be thin in class was very eye opening. I live with a dancer who switched to pharmacy after her freshman year because dancing became so unhealthy for her. I notice that she still is very particular about working out and eating habits. After watching the video last week in class, I went home and talked about it with her. She did say that if you are a dancer your dream would be to be called too thin. It's something they strive for. When she said this I was taken back and kind of shocked. I've always known dancers need to be thin, but to see the extremes they go through is heartbreaking.
ReplyDeleteI was also shocked to find out that insurance doesn't cover treatment for eating disorders; therefore, like the family in the Dr. Phil video that Dr. VanTyle posted, many families go into debt and are torn apart financially and emotionally by the disease. It is scary how prevalent this disease really is, yet it seems to be disregarded in society. I believe we, as pharmacists, can be sources of healthy and valid information for patients. Because patients see so many misleading weight loss ads and advertisements, it is important for us to help them decide what is healthy and realistic for them.
Eating disorders are definitely a very sensitive issue that I believe health care providers are wanting to help with, but really just are not sure how to go about it. As pharmacists we are accustomed to listening to a patient explain their problem and physically giving them something to fix it. As of now, there isn't anything we can physically give these patients to "fix their disorders." This forces us to bring out a different, more compassionate side of our profession. In my very limited experiences with friends who have/had eating disorders, there usually is some root that starts the problem. Many times (not always, I don't mean to generalize) these patients just need someone to understand and sympathize, rather than lecture them about how unhealthy they are.
ReplyDeleteA close friend of mine went through a bad break up early in her college career. She was very upset about it, to the point that she was too depressed to eat. Of course, everyone complimented her on how good she looked and how she's doing a great job "getting fit." It's funny how we are quick to assume that someone losing weight must mean that they're "getting fit" without looking at what is going on behind the scenes. No one knew that they were promoting her unhealthy eating habits. The more compliments she received, the less she ate. Fortunately she started eating again before it became a chronic issue.
Don't get me wrong, I'm all about the positive reinforcement, especially if someone is eating right and exercising to lose a few pounds. I think as health care professionals and as friends, we need to be more aware of the underlying cause before promoting unhealthy habits as well as supportive to those. Sometimes a listening ear is more effective than a medication.
I think Hannah makes a great point in that we need to re-think how we compliment people on their weight. What we may perceive as a compliment may just be aiding and abetting a serious disorder that they have. We need to promote healthy habits, but also be aware of the warning signs of these eating disorders and try to put the pieces together if we can. I know sometimes it's hard to bring it up to a friend or family member who you think may be struggling and they will most likely deny it, but they could also be crying out for help and you could be the difference that saves their life.
ReplyDeleteAs I said in class, I lived with a dancer last year who had an eating disorder. After watching the video, it was amazing how many similarities I saw between her and the other dancers. However, the reality is that not all people are as accepting as the director at the American Ballet Theatre who allowed the dancer time off to seek treatment. From what my friend told me, it is still brushed under the rug a lot. We as a society continue to brush it under the rug by refusing to accept it as a true diagnosis and offer insurance coverage to those seeking treatment. I was amazed to learn of some of the long-term complications of these diseases, especially the osteoporosis. We need to raise awareness and help people get treatment before they cause irreversible damage to their bodies.
I think it's amazing how much this discussion on eating disorders relates to our class discussion last week on women in the media. As long as we continue to put out the message in the media that women need to be thin, they will take drastic measures to do so. As pharmacists, we don't have a clear cut role here. However, we can still be aware of signs to look out for and help those that we know are suffering or recovering from an eating disorder.
I have known enough girls (and a guy) throughout my life with eating disorders to understand that eating disorders are a lot more common than what is perceived by the general public. I will agree with what many of my classmates have said above in saying that this is often because they are not addressed when they should be. It does not help that sometimes the media does just portray them as being a joke, or something less severe than they are. It also does not help that eating disorders are not taking seriously as an illness by insurance companies.
ReplyDeleteI think that what kylie said is interesting about how many of the "signs" of eating disorders is common in many girls that do not appear to have eating disorders. I feel the same way as well. I feel that although someone may not be able to be clinically defined as anorexic or bulimic, that they can still exhibit unhealthy behaviors. Many, many people do this in fact. We are a society that is obsessed with our weight.
I believe that as pharmacists, we have the potential to play an important role in something like this. Pharmacists in retail have a lot of interaction with patients every day. Often times, patients trust their pharmacists more than they trust their doctors. I think that this requires the pharmacist to be knowledgeable about things like eating disorders. Pharmacists can also play a role potentially in the future if pharmacological advances are made, but they still need to be knowledgeable on the disorders.
There was a girl in this video that talked about her parents getting divorced and she was so mad that it made her have an eating disorder, but the video also mentioned that not all children whose parents go through a divorce develop an eating disorder. People who are vulnerable to eating disorders are those who are already exposed to these thoughts before a tragic event. This made me think about the route of the environment. And as many have been saying, these thoughts and actions are encouraged by people around them.
ReplyDeleteThere should be more of an emphasis on well-being as a whole, rather than just the way someone looks, their diet, and their exercise. There is so much more that goes into someone's health.