PCOS
We discussed the pathophysiology and treatment of PCOS and we heard from
a patient who has had the disorder for about 10 years. What are your thoughts?
What if you were suddenly afflicted with a disorder that increased your weight
by 50–100#?
Normal kids gather for Pizza and Soda (neither can be considered
as low carb options) How would that
have affected your high school and college friendships? What do you think about this disorder that
can affect diet choices, weight gain, relationships and incur the “judgment” of
by-standers?
There are challenges to living with it but as we understand it
more – it is rarely associated with infertility when under control.
How do you keep from judging a "book by its cover"?? - it is a quick
reflex by us all. Obesity is not a "character flow" -- no one chooses to be overweight or obese. It s the only accepted bias permitted by our society. Healthcare providers should not have this bias but be prepared to help and assist. What do you usually think when you see an obese patient? Does this challenge your views??
Do you understand Glycemic Index a bit better now? What questions
remain for you? What insights do you have?
The lecture on PCOS was very intriguing. Before this I knew close to nothing about this condition. I would be extremely alarmed if I suddenly gained upwards of 50 lbs, especially if nothing significant had changed in my daily routine. I would probably assume the worst and think there was something drastic and life-threatening wrong with me. Like she said, I assume that this condition has had an impact on her social life. I take for granted the little things like grabbing ice cream with friends and having wine with roommates. If I continually had to say no to these things I would feel left out. I would also imagine that others who did not understand the disease would just say to work out and eat healthier in order to lose the weight. Most people don't believe you when you say that your extra pounds are due to a genetic condition--they view it as an excuse.
ReplyDeleteI definitely think that healthcare providers should be more aware of PCOS. I had no idea that it affected almost 20% of women. Something this common should be emphasized more. I understand the glycemic index more now; it makes sense to me that foods that require more breakdown and processing by the body would have a lower glycemic index and would not raise your blood sugar as much. I think this way of eating could be applicable and beneficial to diabetics and anyone wishing to obtain a healthier lifestyle.
I was very interested in learning more about PCOS coming in to the lecture. My sister was diagnosed with it very recently, so hearing about all the potential health concerns she may face was a little overwhelming. She is a freshman this year, and although she is very active, she has had to make adjustments to how often she goes out to dinner with her friends, and with what she orders. It is a major lifestyle change that can be challenging.
ReplyDeleteI had no idea that it affected 20% of women. I thought it was just some strange thing my sister had. That being said, I'm shocked we don't talk about it more. It would be very easy for a pharmacist who is unaware of PCOS and its medications to incorrectly counsel a patient. Without meaning to, the pharmacist in this situation could easily offend their patient. I definitely agree with what Kelsey said about how people tend to jump to conclusions about claiming genetics as a reason for obesity being an excuse. Prior to learning more about PCOS, I was quick to make that same accusation. Healthcare professionals need to be understanding and not quick to assume.
The glycemic index review was very helpful. I found myself thinking a little more about what I was choosing to eat and how I could make some adjustments to my own diet.
Our discussion last week regarding PCOS was very enlightening. Like Kelsey and Hannah said, it was eye-opening to learn that nearly 20% of women are affected by this. It is alarming that a condition so common is relatively unknown even among healthcare professionals. It is sad that a condition that can drastically change someone's life can go unrecognized for so long.
ReplyDeleteI was really appreciative Rachel came and shared her story with us. The fact that she can share how PCOS has affected her life with pretty much complete strangers is very admirable. Some days are worse than others, but I thought her attitude about everything was inspiring. I am thankful she came to talk to us.
The main thing I think we can take away from our discussion is you can't judge a book by its cover. It is important to treat each person with respect and refrain from judgement. You can't know a person based on appearance or what medications they are on. Every patient is unique, and it is our job to treat them as such.
I really learned a lot from class last week. PCOS is something only briefly mentioned in class, but has never really been explained to us. It was eye opening to see the long term challenges associated with this disease and I hope that it becomes more incorporated into our curriculum in the future since it affect one in five women.
ReplyDeleteI can’t help but relate our lectures to our social media lecture. It would be difficult to be a teenager and suddenly put on a lot of weight with no obvious cause. And especially since PCOS is not a well-known disease, it would be particularly frustrating. The media illustrates that being thin is more favorable and so this disease could really affect one’s relationships, friendships, and self-esteem. In addition I would feel really left out if I couldn't grab a beer with some friends or go out for pizza together.
While I remain unbiased as a healthcare professional, I attributed obesity to our age of technology and convenience and potentially poor eating habits that developed during childhood. However, I never really considered that a disease itself would cause such a weight gain and it is definitely something I will keep in mind in the future.
Like Ryan said, I was really inspired by Rachel's confidence and attitude. I am thankful she came to talk to us even though it may be a personal topic. Discussing with her helped me to understand the reality of PCOS and how it affects people in their daily activities and in the long term. I also agree that the lack of knowledge and education about PCOS is ridiculous. Hopefully that will change soon.
ReplyDeleteWeight gain and management is a tough topic to understand especially if you've never had to deal with it yourself. I confess that it has always been a tough topic for me to understand when I'm constantly hearing from people that it's a matter of self-control. But for many people, it is clearly not simply about self-control. I was challenged yesterday by something my pastor said. "You can't judge others because you don't understand how much mercy God has shown you." Whether you're religious or not, I think this applies here. None of us were given the same cards to play with. No one was born with the same parents, in the same place, at the same time, grew up in the same atmosphere, and did not have the same genetic exposures. I need to stop before I think to judge someone.
The discussion on glycemic index was especially informational for me. Both my parents have diabetes and it has been frustrating for me to not be able to help them in many ways. After last week, I started to incorporate this into my own diet like Hannah. My goal is to be able to help and encourage my parents when my own lifestyle changes.
I really appreciate Rachel coming and talking with us because it gave me a better understanding of what patient's with PCOS go through and how it affects their daily life. I can't imagine how I would feel if I suddenly gained 50 pounds. I have been extremely blessed with really good genetics because during my college years I haven't exactly exercised or eaten the best, but I have lost weight while being at Butler. Because of this, sometimes I just can't understand how people can exercise and eat extremely healthy and still not be able to lose weight. It's challenging for me to understand why people can't lose weight when I can't seem to gain weight. However, learning about PCOS and hearing Rachel's story has really helped me. Just hearing how often she exercised and how much knowledge she has about glycemic index really shows it isn't just how many calories you intake vs how many calories you burn. Genetics and disease states play a big role in this.
ReplyDeleteI also had no idea that it affected 20% of women, and I was really surprised that even doctors weren't very knowledgeable about the disease. I agree that this should definitely be added into our curriculum especially since there are many other complications that could occur down the road and multiple medications for PCOS. Learning about this disease state can be extremely helpful to us not only to be more knowledgeable about the disease but to be more understanding of what our patients may be going through and not "judge a book by its cover".
Before last week I had heard of PCOS, but I had no idea what the disorder was. I am very grateful that Rachel came in and shared her experiences with PCOS with the class. It is one thing to hear and learn about the disorder in class, but nothing can beat talking one on one with a patient who has the disorder and hearing their day to day struggles and first hand perspective. I find it disturbing that so many women have this disorder, yet we, as future pharmacists, would know nothing about it without this class. I also find it interesting that there is not necessarily one diagnostic test to see if you have PCOS, rather you come to the diagnosis by symptoms and ruling out other disorders.
ReplyDeleteWhile Rachel was speaking I tried to put myself into her shoes. Freshman year of high school is a scary time for everyone with a lot of new changes and responsibilities. I could not imagine gaining 50-100 lbs in that period of time. It would be so difficult to handle emotionally and kids in high school can be very cruel when it comes to weight as well. Trying to eat a diet low in carbs and trying to understand the idea of glycemic index at such a young age, along with complying with new medications you are being put on, is also a lot of added stress and responsibility. With all of this added stress, the last thing patient's with PCOS should have to worry about is being judged by healthcare professionals. This is why it is always important to keep an open mind, talk to patients, and find out their PMH before judging them on their looks alone.
I am really glad Rachel came to class to talk to us about PCOS. I knew very little if anything at all about this before class. Its name alone is very misleading as to what is actually involved. I did not know that it had to do with insulin and weight gain. Learning about the rapid weight gain and the use of metformin as a treatment makes me realize that I cannot assume that someone on metformin is diabetic. When I have people ask me what their Metformin is for I always explain for your diabetes or your sugar. I realize that I will have to change the way I explain this now.
ReplyDeleteThis year for my new year’s resolution I decided that I would try not to judge people based on appearance or first impressions. I realized that I have no idea what their journey has been just as they have no idea of mine. This has proven to be difficult especially at work, but when I find myself casting judgment I remind myself that I would not want to be judged which helps. Learning about PCOS makes me realize just how important it is not to judge someone.
I've always known of PCOS, but I never really have had the opportunity to learn all of the details. I really appreciated Rachel coming into class to discuss her personal experiences with us. It takes a lot of courage to be comfortable discussing those things with strangers.
ReplyDeleteIn middle school I had some difficulty with my weight myself, and since then I've cut out soda from my diet and have always avoided processed foods when I can. I can understand feeling distanced from your peers in this aspect. I have always felt judgement when I've attempted to avoid certain foods. Such as friends or family thinking I'm "anorexic" when really I am just trying to stay healthy.
I think it is really important for people to not assume that everyone that is obese or overweight is that way because they eat too much or refrain from exercising. It is a very unfair assumption. I especially think that pharmacists, as healthcare providers, should be understanding to the idea that obesity can be caused by medical conditions. It is very surprising to me that many health care providers are not completely aware of PCOS, especially with its prevalence.
something interesting that goes along with our LGBT topic.... I read that Facebook finally added a "custom" gender setting. This allows anyone that doesn't identify with male or female to change the gender to whatever they identify with. I found it interesting, so I thought I would share. :)
I am really glad that we spent last class talking about PCOS. Like most of my classmates have stated above, I'm shocked that this disease is so prevalent yet we don't cover it in our curriculum and most people don't even know about it. I thought it was just a disease affecting your ovaries and possibly your fertility. I had no idea that it was associated with all of the metabolic and hormonal changes and that there are some variations where you don't even have cysts on your ovaries. Hearing Rachel's point of view was great, too. It always helps to humanize a disease state and see the impact that it has on your quality of life.
ReplyDeleteRachel's story and our discussion in class made me realize that obesity isn't always something that we can control. It is easy to be quick to judge and assume someone is lazy or has no self-control if they are obese, but that's not always the case. It was good to be reminded to not be so quick to judge based on appearances. This goes back to our first class, because we live in a society that teaches us to judge off appearances and that we all need to be model skinny. We need to start accepting a new ideal of beauty that's more representative of the true American women and what's on the inside rather than just on looks.
The biggest thing that struck be about using the glycemic index is how difficult it would be to adjust, especially as a college student. You can't just pick anything out of the cafeteria or out of the vending machine. You have to calculate and consciously think about what you're putting in your body and how that will affect you. I know I would have difficulty complying with that. I think as healthcare providers we are able to help our patients understand these lifestyle changes they are going to have to make. And if we have friends or family members who need to follow this diet, we need to take that into consideration before we suggest a restaurant or recipe.
Lastly, I found this very interesting video the other day about one woman's journey with PCOS: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rgQjfcpG7XY
It discusses her struggle with bullying, but her ultimate acceptance of her diagnosis. She has chosen not to shave her beard, yet I was amazed at her self-confidence. I think she's very courageous and offers a unique perspective on this disease.
having rachel come into talk to us was a great experience in understanding some the struggles that patients are challenged with. Dr. Vantyles positive attitude regarding the repeated attempts on rachel's medications to treat her PCOS symptoms is something that i will try to implement when serving patients. as a pharmacist down the road we sometimes will have the ability to see a patients medical history and be able to provide great support and encouragement.
ReplyDeleteI thought it was a great point that PCOS is more common than what most people think and can lead to an improper initial diagnosis. I'm grateful to have a new found knowledge on a disease state that so many of us students know nothing about.