Monday, March 3, 2014

Feb 25 - Domestic Violence

Domestic violence:

(2-25-14) we discussed Domestic Violence and had Prof. Michele Schultz as a guest speaker.  Once again, we are asked not to judge but to help.  "Why don't they just leave?" becomes a very tough question to answer.  Some people can look back into the individual's life and think - they just did not receive enough love as a child' or 'they had a very hard life growing up'.  “If I could just love him/her enough, she/he would not be this way”

Important to understand is that this is about violence and you cannot love someone else enough to make it go away.  As we discussed with eating disorders - you have to love yourself and respect  yourself - self-love comes from the individual and others cannot love you enough to make up for whatever is going on.  The cycle of violence continues.  


Domestic violence is commonly misunderstood to be about hitting and physical abuse but it more commonly starts with isolation of the victim from family and friends then control of finances to exert control over another person.  Most are threatened to remain silent.  Many feel like they are always "walking on eggshells" to avoid confrontation which can be violent.  It can involve the spouse, the children or even pets.

You will find yourself at some time in your life looking at a relationship and thinking - this does not look good or I don't like the sound of what I am hearing.  I hope you will be at the right place and time to listen and refer the individual to help or before it goes too far - to suggest that the relationship does not sound healthy.  Have you had any such opportunities so far?  What questions do you have?  Any comments to share?  Again post anonymously if you wish

13 comments:

  1. I found this topic of violence both shocking and eye opening. I was one of those people who said “why didn’t she (or he) just leave” or “how could you marry someone who does that.” I personally had a friend who married her high-school sweet heart who eventually began abusing her and her children. I never understood how she could marry such a person and allow it to happen. He used the same tactics described in the video we watched about isolating her from friends and family with complete control of her life. Everything he did was about control and he use to play the most heinous mind games. She used the same phrase to describe how she felt of “walking on egg shells” a lot. After getting close to this woman and her friends, I started to realize that it is possible. She was a strong, independent woman who married a man that even her closest friends called “Mr. Perfect.” People had known this man and his family his whole life and never thought anything like this could have happened. I think it is scary knowing this sort of violence can manifest even when you are certain a person is not capable of it. The worst part is that she thought it was her fault.

    I found it surprising that the woman in the video we watched in class was abused by her husband a few days before she married him. I have never personally been in a situation like this but after helping a friend through a similar situation and speaking about this topic in class, I can understand how it is hard to walk away. I have a greater appreciation for helping those who are victims of domestic violence and have learned that being a supportive friend can make all the difference. I know when I go to work next, I will be more observant for the signs of someone who is a victim of violence and know how to help if the situation presents.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have learned a lot about domestic violence during the last few years, because it was the philanthropy of my sorority. However, it never fails to shock me that such a huge problem continues to go on, mostly behind closed doors. I think what strikes me the most is that domestic violence can affect anyone. The TED talk was great, because I think the speaker is someone that not many people would have identified as at risk for domestic violence, but she showed that it does not discriminate.
    A few years ago, I had a roommate who came home in tears one night after her boyfriend had verbally and physically abused her. We supported her and her decision to break up with him, but they were back together in less than a week. Unfortunately, our disagreement over the health of the relationship ended up ruining our friendship. She is still dating him and I hope the abuse has stopped, but I think one time is one time too many.
    I think that it's important that we also talked about the difficulty women have in leaving their abusers. I never really thought about a women needing to stay with her husband to keep health coverage for herself and kids, but I can also see how that could make the decision even more difficult. We need to think about the whole picture to better walk inside the victim's shoes.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think the biggest thing I took away from our discussion last week was that domestic violence is not simply about physical abuse. Obviously, the physical violence is what most people worry about, but the other factors typically involved were very eye-opening. The isolation and techniques to manipulate a victim were pretty shocking. I couldn't imagine the emotional and psychological effects this abuse would have on a person. I think we've all had arguments and disputes with a significant other, but I could never imagine a situation like the ones we saw in class.

    I thought the women in the videos were inspiring with their courage to speak about their experiences. I know it had to be very difficult to relive such a dark time in their lives. Hopefully these stories can bring increased awareness to the true nature of domestic violence and fewer women (and men) will be affected by this in the future. Unmasking the truths about domestic violence will hopefully decrease its prevalence in the future.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think Kylie said it best, this topic was "eye-opening and shocking." I've heard multiple lectures on domestic violence, but until recently, I never really heard the personal stories. I guess it was naive of me to think that if he or she really wanted to, they could just walk away and find someone who would treat them better. I also used to think that you would be able to tell who "potential" abusers were by how they acted, what they wore, etc. Reflecting on that now, I see how shallow this thinking was. I was also surprised at how the most dangerous times in a domestic violence relationship were when the victim left the relationship, searching for help. It makes sense that this would make the abuser angry, but I guess I always assumed that by leaving the victim would instantly be safe. Escaping is definitely a longer, more intense process than I understood.
    Just a couple of weeks ago, a friend called and told me how her boyfriend of over a year had hit her, and they fought to the point that the cops needed to be called. Without thinking, my first words were, "I can't believe that he would do that! He seemed so perfect for you!" I made it clear that I was on her side and there to support her, but my first comment should have been along the lines of "are you okay" and "do you need somewhere to go." After last class, I am more aware of how I respond to these situations and how to be supportive. What's worrying me now is that this friend recently told me he called her, apologizing, saying it wouldn't happen again, and started the sweet-talking. I'm seeing warning signs, but how do you explain that to a grown, strong woman who wants desperately to believe him?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I definitely used to be one of those people that thought "why don't they just leave?" Until I had a friend in high school that opened my eyes to why this isn't so easy. Her father passed away when she was only a few weeks old and her mother shortly remarried. This man was very abusive and the story of her parents was very similar to the video we watched in class. He beat her mom on the night of their wedding. I just couldn't fathom how someone could stay in a relationship like that. However, they ended up staying together for almost 20 years. I saw how it affected not only the wife but my friend as well. She ended up going on to marry someone who was abusive. It really made me realize that this man had almost convinced them both that this type of behavior was normal. It was really difficult for me to watch her go through something like that, and I wish I would have known more about domestic violence back then. I definitely agreed with the lady in the video that said domestic violence is not cyclic. Sometimes people think that they are being abused at one point but then the abuser can be really nice and loving the next. But this is only a tactic that the abuser uses. Hearing the stories about my friend's step dad allowed me to easily see as an outsider that he was extremely manipulative. I think this is a concept that is important to recognize with domestic violence.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you all - great comments.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I thought last week’s class was one of our most powerful classes. One major lesson I took away was that domestic violence can occur in relationships of any age and economic status. It can easily be a relationship that a close friend is in and you may have no idea. Unfortunately, I had a friend who was in an emotionally and physically abusive relationship, but I was not even aware of it until months after the relationship was over. It was at first very surprising because she comes off as a very strong, happy, independent person so it was incredibly frustrating not knowing and not being able to help or support her.

    Being the victim in the scenarios, I was really taken off guard by some of the first responses. It would take a lot of courage in the first place to ask for help and to have every single person that I turned to for escape turn me down, shut me out, tell me I was crazy, or that it was my fault would be absolutely devastating. Without any support I would easily start to question whether or not I deserved this treatment and whether or not the relationship was my fault.

    Through this class, I learned that domestic violence is a condition embedded in psychological control; whether it is through taking advantage of a lack of self-worth or a desire to love the hate out of the abuser. As a result, it is imperative that healthcare professionals always be supportive and ask questions during health checkups. A doctor or other member of the healthcare field may be one of the safest people to confide in and so it is important that there is a way to screen for domestic abuse in a healthcare setting.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree with others in that last week's class was one of the most eye-opening so far. Looking at the things that lead to violence and the types of things that lead up to an abusive and violent relationship really put things in a different perspective for me. Looking back on things now, I realize that I've seen relationships where certain things in the power and control wheel were definitely occurring and I had no idea that they were in any way related to an abusive relationship.

    As we discussed a bit in class, often domestic abuse happens from someone you would never expect. To me, this was a scary thing to discuss. As a person who has been in a relationship for 3+ years, I was thinking how incredibly difficult it would be to have to deal with someone I've grown to love and trust completely becoming abusive. Something like that would complete turn a person's life upside down, and the person would have no control over it.

    The TED talk and the personal stories were really powerful to me. It was really shocking listening to the women's different personal stories. The stories seemed to have the common factor that the signs of abuse were not clear in the relationship in the beginning though.

    ReplyDelete
  9. My oldest sister was in an abusive marriage for 5 years. I witnessed firsthand some very awkward encounters between her and her husband; it was a very tough situation. I was very involved in school and sports, so I didn't really deal with it much, but my mom did. She would have to take my sister to the hospital for injuries to her wrists and such. At first she would say she fell down the stairs carrying laundry, but after so many injuries it became evident that these injuries weren’t from accidents. It was a tough situation for everyone because my sister wouldn't leave him and has 2 children with him. Eventually her husband wouldn't allow her to work and controlled every penny she could have. Basically, everything that we talked about in class happened to my sister.
    One night it got really bad and the cops were called yet again. This was the night my sister decided she had to leave him for her and her kids’ safety. The state's attorney decided to bring criminal charges on her husband. There was a jury trial and I was forced to testify. Because I have been so close to a situation with domestic violence, I have strong feelings against it and have been cautious with relationships in my own life.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I did not realize how widespread of an issue that domestic violence is. One of my best friends that I met here at Butler has been in very stressful relationships. In high school, she successfully obtained a restraining order against a boyfriend. He would make her take pictures of herself to prove that she was at the gym. She then said that she reached her breaking point when she was on vacation with her family and realized that he had isolated her from the ones who were closest to her. She then got into another emotionally unstable relationship about two years ago. He was turning her against all of us as her friends. After learning about how to deal with people that are in unstable relationships, I wish I would have handled the situation a little better. She would just stress all of us out so much with crying and complaining about him, but then go back to him the next day. I wish I could have continued to be more supportive but I was too frustrated. I think it is a vital skill that everyone should have -- to be able to give support to those that are in emotionally or physically abusive relationships.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This weeks topic was very difficult for me to listen to and watch. My sister has been in a relationship for 19 years with a man who treats her this way. Unfortunately she does not see what the rest of the family and friends see. He is verbally abusive, economically abusive and isolates her from us. I think that the biggest reason she does not see it is because the abuse has not been very physical. In those 19 years he has only been physical with her twice. The first was bad but the second was horrible. The second time he physically beat her and raped her, with her children and two of mine in the other room. The children heard her screams for help but were too young to understand or know what they should do. She escaped and drove a short distance to my brothers who went to get the children. Her husband than proceeded to burn their house down after everyone left. That was one of the worst days of my life because when I heard of the fire I thought my children were dead.
    My sister left him after that and he went to jail. Unfortunately he got out sweet talked her and after only six months she went back to him. That happened almost 4 years ago, and to this day she doesn't bring him to any family functions. Sometimes it's hard to understand why someone would want to stay after that,but when you meet someone at 16, and they are all you know, its easier to stay with the familiar even when its not good than to try to start all over again. I can't be 100% certain that he will do this again any more than she can be 100% certain he won't. I feel that if he ever does snap and do this again she won't walk away from it. I am honestly not sure what you say to someone who doesn't see what you see.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Reading all these stories by our classmates gives me the chills. Domestic violence just happens too commonly. This discussion changed the way I view domestic violence: the horror in being stuck in such a risky, isolated situation became real. It made me want to be more cautious about my relationships and my friend's relationships. I have been guilty of thinking that everyone can change and I can help them, but I will never take comments on violence lightly anymore.

    The exercise we did together in class made me feel awful, yet empowered. It's true that the words you speak can be both destructive and bring hope into someone's life. I'm thinking specifically the difference in impact between "how could he do that to you?" and "you are brave for speaking up." It made such a huge difference and I could even feel it as I was reading my lines.

    I still have several questions after our discussion. What is the best thing to do for the abusers? When do the women finally start feeling like they are not at risk, if ever?

    ReplyDelete
  13. The day Dr. Schultz came into our classroom to talk to all of us made me realize that that things i have witnessed and experienced in the past fall under the term of domestic violence. and i dont know if it was because of denile or of ignorance, but it was never labeled as domestic violence since nobody was physically injured. i cant help but to think how events in my life and the lives of my friends may have been changed if i had recognized the signs, even if they were non-physical.

    After watching the videos of women who had been in this type of relationship and learning of the warning signs to domestic violence it really just makes me wonder if this was a factor in in relationships of friends and of my divorced parents.

    Regarding how to handle these types of situations, i feel that it would have been great to know how to confront and address the abuser of the violence that he or she is causing.

    ReplyDelete