Wednesday, February 5, 2014

Feb 4 - LGBT Issues in Health Care

The video from the NY Health Department was really about respect and understanding.  What are your thoughts and responses on LGBT issues?  Other questions you want to ask?  You can email me and I can ask Dr. Beloso (of Butler GWSS program) for guidance - if you want to be anonymous.  Notice forms you  fill out at a Doctors office or medical history and the boxes available to check. We do not go out of our way to make it easy for LGBT patients to find their family dynamic.

13 comments:

  1. I thought the video was very interesting. I guess I never realized how close minded our health care system is when it comes to the LGBT population. I didn't realize that many of our forms don't provide them an option. But what appalled me the most was the story from the video about the man who could not go back into the emergency room with his partner. To me, that is just wrong.As a health care provider, we are supposed to care for our patient, no tell them who they are and are not allowed to love. I am hoping that as the generations become more open-minded to the LGBT population, health care professionals will follow suit by correcting their forms and policies to be more welcoming to all patients, regardless of their gender orientation.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I left thinking about the generational differences too. I hope that we will be more open to changes in our culture, even though there are so many differences.

      Delete
  2. I found the issue of LGBT patients in the medical system very interesting. I am at Barnes Hospital this weekend and I have had to fill out many forms for myself and my father. I have noticed there are only boxes for gender asking female or male. There is no other or space to add another option. They also have marital status of only single, married, divorced, or widowed. I never took the time to think about how a patient that is LGBT would feel about filling out these forms. They may not be married but that doesn’t mean they haven’t had a partner for 10 years. I did like how the nurses asked here who each of us were. They did not assume I was his daughter. They ask an open ended question so you can address what relationship you have with the patient.
    I also liked the video because it discussed ways to avoid making assumptions and still addressing patients as they would like to be addressed as a health care worker. Asking “what is your relationship status” or “how do you identify” instead of checking a box can tell you a lot about a person. It also builds trust by accepting the answers the patient gives you instead of giving looks of disapproval. I would hope that with all the strides that have been taken with civil rights and equality, our health care system would follow suit and bring the best care possible to all patients.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am really glad LGTBQ in healthcare was a topic we discussed in this class because there has been little to no information about it in any of our other courses (although I think Self-Care could potentially add it or at least address it). At first I wasn’t sure what exactly we would talk about other than potential medical conditions that the LGTBQ population may be more predisposed to (such as smoking). As someone studying in the healthcare field, I have always felt that the patient’s care comes first. Despite your own opinions about personal life-style choices, they should never interfere with a patient’s health and the quality of service they experience as a patient. So I was very shocked to hear some of the stories in class of the prejudice they faced. I really hope one's gender and sexual identity becomes less of an issue in the future. Changing forms to be more applicable to different gender and sexual identities would be a good start and would also allow members of the LGTBQ community to feel more assured that they will be treated accurately and with respect.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm really glad we talked about this topic, because I learned a lot and feel much more comfortable dealing with LGBTQ patients in the future. I think the important point that many people are missing is that it's not necessarily about accepting their way of life, but it's about having respect for others. As Dr. VanTyle pointed out, I think this issue is to our generation what civil rights and racism was to our parents generation. I feel that most of our generation is much more accepting because we have more exposure to it and we are more open-minded. However, it's still important to be educated on the unique issues facing LGBTQ population and how to best serve them as healthcare professionals.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This last week's discussion about LGBTQ issues in healthcare was very insightful. Though this is an undeniably growing population, I think it is an population generally ignored in the healthcare profession. Like Kylie stated and the video showed over and over, healthcare forms tend to shun members of the LBGTQ community. This can only lead to distrust and isn't good for the patient or the provider.

    I think our education regarding the issues facing the LGBTQ community in healthcare is something that needs to be addressed as well. We receive little to no education on this topic which probably contributes to this problem. I think increasing awareness across all healthcare professions can decrease the negative experiences LGBTQ patients have with the healthcare system. If healthcare professionals are not aware of some the issues facing this community, they are less likely to approach these patients with empathy. In this day and age, ignorance can not be an excuse. All patients deserve respect regardless of their sexual/gender identity.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This discussion has probably been the most eye opening for me so far. I was not aware of the difficulty that the LGBT community has with something as simple as filling out a form at the doctor’s office. Not being able to accurately identify on the form can hinder their healthcare. If the doctor is not perceptive enough to ask questions appropriately then it may never come out that they are gay or lesbian. This will then lead the doctor to not suggest appropriate tests that could be lifesaving. I can’t imagine how someone would feel filling out a form and thinking none of these applies to me. I personally would want to cross them out and write in what was appropriate for me. I feel this could make them frustrated before they were ever even seen by a doctor. This would affect the treatment they receive.

    I have a very close male friend that is gay. He is very open and honest and whenever I have questions about the LGBT community he always answers for me. I never thought to ask him how he feels about going to the doctor or about the forms that he has to fill out. I too feel that as healthcare professionals we need more training and information with this patient population. I also feel that all healthcare professionals in general need to be taught more and to learn how to be compassionate and treat everyone with respect, regardless of our own personal opinions or beliefs.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I agree with Hannah in the fact that I did not realize how close minded our health system is. I never really thought that LGBT patients should be treated differently, but by not acknowledging their particular situation, we are unintentionally negatively affecting their outcomes. Regardless of your personal beliefs or religious views, I think as health professionals we should do whatever possible to appropriately treat our patients. We cannot be afraid or intimidated by something that we do not know ourselves. It is our job to remain open minded and deliver an unbiased service to patients.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree with what many people have said above. I had never thought of how the LGBT community would feel while filling out those forms. I never noticed it before, but now it does surprise me that was such a large number of people that don't fit into the categories they offer that they haven't changed them yet. I agree that we should have more education on this population. I think that having compassion is one of the most important characteristics for a health care provider and that includes being compassionate to everyone you meet. So even increasing awareness about this population and how they would like to be treated in a health care setting could be beneficial. I also never thought that knowing their sexual orientation could be a big impact on the health care they receive. If physicians don't ask the right questions they may never find out and could not treat the patient in the best way possible. This was a very interesting topic that I had not heard hardly anything about before so it was very helpful.

    ReplyDelete
  9. As many people already said, this topic was never talked about in any other class even though it is very necessary. I believe that it's the unknown that make people so disrespectful. Raising awareness is so critical, especially because there is a growing population of LGBT community. I will definitely be more aware now that I understand it better.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I am very glad we talked about this topic in class. To be honest, it is something I have never thought of in relation to healthcare or pharmacy before. Watching the video in class helped open my eyes and made me think about how I would handle some of the situations presented. I now feel more knowledgeable and comfortable addressing the LGBT community. I also thought it was helpful to go over the true definitions of gender, sex, etc. I think it is important to know these basic definitions. Knowing these definitions will help avoid miscommunications and will help prevent possibly offending a patient in the future. This is a sensitive subject, but one that I am very glad was addressed in this class.

    ReplyDelete
  11. i feel that addressing the needs for someone with a LGBT background and showing them the same respect as every other patient helps to form a positive relationship with doctors and healthcare professionals. It was great to see that the people of New York took a strong initiative to addressing equality in patient care settings because this is a topic often not discussed. With gay marriage and gay rights being frequently challenged in our generation, i feel that to be successful in healthcare people should be educated on how to respect those who are gay or transgender in order to provide optimal care for each patient. As mentioned in the video, some pateint forms do not have the ability for LGBT specifications. Granting someone the option to accurately select the proper medical history in describing their gay or transgender sex would be a great place to start for creating a comfortable and respectful environment.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This topic really opened up my mind to an entire area of health care that I had never really spent much time thinking about before. The video especially provided a unique perspective on some very big issues in healthcare for the LBGT community. Thinking back on my own experiences with doctors, many do not provide a comfortable environment for anyone that is not a straight male or female. I've also had experiences working with older pharmacists that talked about some patient's in a negative why while they were in the store. I was happy to see that it was a topic that we were going to cover in class because I knew that it would not be covered in any other course. In general, the reason why I took this course is because I knew it would provide me with a learning opportunity that I could not get in any other course in pharmacy school. I've been very pleased with the eye opening discussions that we've had so far in class.

    ReplyDelete